Bartholomew Pettit and Sarah Ann (Elizabeth) Butts

Bartholomew Pettit married Aarah Ann Butts, daughter of Zedekiah Butts and Margaret Grant, and settled in Delaware county, Ohio.


Husband: Bartholomew + Pettit (1)


Born: 1793 – , , Delaware (2)
Christened:
Died: 1850 Abt – Brown, Delaware, Ohio
Buried:
Marriage: 1823 Apr 17 Place: , Muskingum, Ohio (3)


Events


1. Census: 1830 Bush Creek, Muskingum, Ohio. (4)

1830 OHIO MUSKINGUM BUSH CREEK
Jonathan CARLILE
William DONALDSON
David MARTIN
Margaret L. MOORE
Abraham BESFORD?
Jacob PETTIT or PELLET – – – – 1 / – – – – – 1 (1 deaf and dumb white
person of age 14 and under 25)
James L. MOORE (ELMORE)
Ann BROWN
Isaac DUTTON
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 – – – – 1 / 2 1 – – 1
Reuben WHITAKER
Francis KING
(next page)
Edmund BARBER
David BUTT 1 – – 1 – – 1 /1 2 2 – 1 1
Peter SHORT
Jacob AUSTIN?
Ann TRIPLETE?
Hazel BUTT – 1 – – 1 / – 1 – – 1
James HOPKIN
John MOSTAL
Zedekiah BUTT – – 1 – – – – – – 1 / – – – 1 – – – 1
John KING
Christian BAHGHMAN

2. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio. (5)

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.

3. Census: 1850 Brown, Delaware, Ohio. (6) 1850 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 241
1971/1982 Henry CARHART 60 farmer b. NY
Clarrisa 60 b. CONN
Elliott 22 b. NY
Marinda 14 b. NY
Camilla OSGOOD 10 b. OH
Clarissa 8
Ralph 2

BROWN TOWNSHIP
pg. 304
2862/2826 Bartholomew PETIT 57 $2100 farmer b. DEL
Sarah Ann 46 b. MD
Jacob F. 25 farmer b. OH
Eliza 22
Sarah J. 12
Abe ? 8


Wife: Sarah Ann (Elizabeth) + Butts (1)


AKA: Sarah Pettit
Born: 1804 – , , Maryland (7)
Christened:
Died: 1850 aft
Buried:
Father: Zedekiah (+) Butts (1770- )
Mother: Margaret (+) Grant (1770- )


Events


1. Census: 1830 Bush Creek, Muskingum, Ohio. (4)

1830 OHIO MUSKINGUM BUSH CREEK
Jonathan CARLILE
William DONALDSON
David MARTIN
Margaret L. MOORE
Abraham BESFORD?
Jacob PETTIT or PELLET – – – – 1 / – – – – – 1 (1 deaf and dumb white
person of age 14 and under 25)
James L. MOORE (ELMORE)
Ann BROWN
Isaac DUTTON
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 – – – – 1 / 2 1 – – 1
Reuben WHITAKER
Francis KING
(next page)
Edmund BARBER
David BUTT 1 – – 1 – – 1 /1 2 2 – 1 1
Peter SHORT
Jacob AUSTIN?
Ann TRIPLETE?
Hazel BUTT – 1 – – 1 / – 1 – – 1
James HOPKIN
John MOSTAL
Zedekiah BUTT – – 1 – – – – – – 1 / – – – 1 – – – 1
John KING
Christian BAHGHMAN

2. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio. (5)

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.

3. Census: 1850 Brown, Delaware, Ohio. (6)

1850 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 241
1971/1982 Henry CARHART 60 farmer b. NY
Clarrisa 60 b. CONN
Elliott 22 b. NY
Marinda 14 b. NY
Camilla OSGOOD 10 b. OH
Clarissa 8
Ralph 2

BROWN TOWNSHIP
pg. 304
2862/2826 Bartholomew PETIT 57 $2100 farmer b. DEL
Sarah Ann 46 b. MD
Jacob F. 25 farmer b. OH
Eliza 22
Sarah J. 12
Abe ? 8


Children


1 F Female Pettit
Born: 1825-1830 Abt
Christened:
Died: Unknown
Buried:
Spouse:
Marr. Date:


Events


1. Census: 1830 Bush Creek, Muskingum, Ohio. (4)

Unaccounted for female child appears to be in the 1830 census.

1830 OHIO MUSKINGUM BUSH CREEK
Jonathan CARLILE
William DONALDSON
David MARTIN
Margaret L. MOORE
Abraham BESFORD?
Jacob PETTIT or PELLET – – – – 1 / – – – – – 1 (1 deaf and dumb white
person of age 14 and under 25)
James L. MOORE (ELMORE)
Ann BROWN
Isaac DUTTON
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 – – – – 1 / 2 1 – – 1
Reuben WHITAKER
Francis KING
(next page)
Edmund BARBER
David BUTT 1 – – 1 – – 1 /1 2 2 – 1 1
Peter SHORT
Jacob AUSTIN?
Ann TRIPLETE?
Hazel BUTT – 1 – – 1 / – 1 – – 1
James HOPKIN
John MOSTAL
Zedekiah BUTT – – 1 – – – – – – 1 / – – – 1 – – – 1
John KING
Christian BAHGHMAN

2. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio. (5)

Unaccounted for female born about 1825.

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.


2 M Jacob F. Pettit (7)
Born: 1825 – , , Ohio
Christened:
Died: Unknown
Buried:
Spouse:
Marr. Date:


Events


1. Census: 1830 Bush Creek, Muskingum, Ohio. (4)

1830 OHIO MUSKINGUM BUSH CREEK
Jonathan CARLILE
William DONALDSON
David MARTIN
Margaret L. MOORE
Abraham BESFORD?
Jacob PETTIT or PELLET – – – – 1 / – – – – – 1 (1 deaf and dumb white
person of age 14 and under 25)
James L. MOORE (ELMORE)
Ann BROWN
Isaac DUTTON
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 – – – – 1 / 2 1 – – 1
Reuben WHITAKER
Francis KING
(next page)
Edmund BARBER
David BUTT 1 – – 1 – – 1 /1 2 2 – 1 1
Peter SHORT
Jacob AUSTIN?
Ann TRIPLETE?
Hazel BUTT – 1 – – 1 / – 1 – – 1
James HOPKIN
John MOSTAL
Zedekiah BUTT – – 1 – – – – – – 1 / – – – 1 – – – 1
John KING
Christian BAHGHMAN

2. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio. (5)

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.


3 F Eliza Pettit (6)
Born: 1828 – , , Ohio
Christened:
Died: Unknown
Buried:
Spouse:
Marr. Date:


Events


1. Census: 1830 Bush Creek, Muskingum, Ohio. (4)

1830 OHIO MUSKINGUM BUSH CREEK
Jonathan CARLILE
William DONALDSON
David MARTIN
Margaret L. MOORE
Abraham BESFORD?
Jacob PETTIT or PELLET – – – – 1 / – – – – – 1 (1 deaf and dumb white
person of age 14 and under 25)
James L. MOORE (ELMORE)
Ann BROWN
Isaac DUTTON
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 – – – – 1 / 2 1 – – 1
Reuben WHITAKER
Francis KING
(next page)
Edmund BARBER
David BUTT 1 – – 1 – – 1 /1 2 2 – 1 1
Peter SHORT
Jacob AUSTIN?
Ann TRIPLETE?
Hazel BUTT – 1 – – 1 / – 1 – – 1
James HOPKIN
John MOSTAL
Zedekiah BUTT – – 1 – – – – – – 1 / – – – 1 – – – 1
John KING
Christian BAHGHMAN

2. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio. (5)

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.


4 M Male Pettit
Born: 1830-1835 Abt
Christened:
Died: Unknown
Buried:
Spouse:
Marr. Date:


Events


1. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio.

Unaccounted for male born about 1830 to 1835.

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.


5 F Margaret E. + Pettit (1)
Born: 1830 Jan 21 – Zanesville, Muskingum, Ohio
Christened:
Died: 1914 Aug 10 – Macon, Macon, Missouri
Buried: – Oakwood Cemetery
Spouse: Elliot + Carhart (1828-1905)
Marr. Date: 1850 Sep 29
Spouse:
Marr. Date:


Events


1. Religion: Presbyterian.

2. Census: 1830 Bush Creek, Muskingum, Ohio. (4)

1830 OHIO MUSKINGUM BUSH CREEK
Jonathan CARLILE
William DONALDSON
David MARTIN
Margaret L. MOORE
Abraham BESFORD?
Jacob PETTIT or PELLET – – – – 1 / – – – – – 1 (1 deaf and dumb white
person of age 14 and under 25)
James L. MOORE (ELMORE)
Ann BROWN
Isaac DUTTON
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 – – – – 1 / 2 1 – – 1
Reuben WHITAKER
Francis KING
(next page)
Edmund BARBER
David BUTT 1 – – 1 – – 1 /1 2 2 – 1 1
Peter SHORT
Jacob AUSTIN?
Ann TRIPLETE?
Hazel BUTT – 1 – – 1 / – 1 – – 1
James HOPKIN
John MOSTAL
Zedekiah BUTT – – 1 – – – – – – 1 / – – – 1 – – – 1
John KING
Christian BAHGHMAN

3. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio. (5)

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.

4. Census: 1860 Brown, Delaware, Ohio. (8)

1860 OH, Delaware Co., Brown, Kilbourne PO
Pg. 55
827/785 Elliott CARHART 32 farmer $400 $300 b. NY
Margaret 30 b. OH
Eliza 8
Arlington 6

5. Census: 1870 Macon, Macon, Missouri. (9)

1870 Macon County, Missouri census
87/92 CARHART E. 42 Carpenter $1500 property value, $200 personal value
b. NY
Margaret 39 b. OH
Ida 18 b. OH
Arlington 16 b. OH
C. 9 (in school) b. OH
Arthur 3 b. OH
Rosa 1 b. MO

6. Census: 1880 Macon, Macon, Missouri. (10)

1880 Macon County, Missouri census, Macon City Township
Jaskiny Street?
121/129
CARHART Elliot 52 Carpenter b. NY Father b. Conn. Mother b. Conn.
Margaret 50 keeping house b. OH Father b. Del Mother b. MD
Ida M. 28 schoolteacher b. OH
Carrington 19 at school b. OH
Arthur S. 13 at school b. MO
Rosella 11 at home b. MO
Lena B. 9 b. MO
Editha A. 6 b. MO
To one side was a Charles HESSON (?) a lawyer born in Prussia, with wife
Carrie, and an Abner GILSTRAP, also a lawyer, with wife Julia. To the
other side lived a Reuben ELBURMAN (?) with wife Sarah, also a lawyer, a
Frances M. TAYLOR, an editor and printer, with wife Josephine, and a
Franklin AMES, also a lawyer.

7. Census: 1900 Macon, Macon, Missouri. (11)

1900 MISSOURI, MACON CO., MACON CITY, WARD ONE
pg. 125a
Rutherford St.
43/43
MITCHELL Robt. G. b. Oct. 1852/53? 47 yoa married 8 years b. MO., Father
b. VA. Mother b. Missouri atty at law
Lena Bell b. March 1878 28 2 children, 2 surviving b. MO father b. NY
Mother b. OH
Margaret B. Oct. 1892 7 b. MO., in school
Robt. C. March 1895 5 b. MO
Next door was a John A. TURNER, also an atty at law. And in the next
house, pg. 125b is Elliot CARHART.
45/45
CARHART Elliot March 1828 72 married 49 ys. NY Father b. NY mother b.
Conn. carpenter
Margaret b. Jan. 1830 70 7 children with 6 surviving b. OH, father b.
Delaware, mother b. VA
Ida M. b. April 1852 48 OH teacher in high school
Rosa b. 1869 31 MO teacher
Edith b. 1873 26 MO teacher
Next door lived John ERWIN a shoemaker born in Ohio, and Ace ERWIN and
family, a barber.

8. Census: 1910 Macon, Macon, Missouri. (12)

1910 MISSOURI, MACON CO., MACON CITY, WARD ONE
Jackson Street. 1148/95/99
CARHART Margaret E. 80 wd. b. OH father b. Del. Mother b. VA
Ida M. 56 b. OH watercolor artist
Edith A. 37 b. MO teaches music in school
On one side lives Charles ERWIN, a shoemaker, and on the other, Nathaniel
M. SHETTON, a circuit court judge.
Further down the page on N. Rutherford St., 1102/101/105
MITCHELL Lena 39, given as married, 7 children with 6 surviving b. MO
father b. NY mother b. OH
Gwynette 17 b. MO
Robert C. 14 b. MO
John C. 8 b.MO
Dorothy 6 b. MO
Lawrence C. 3 b. MO
Benjamin C. 1 and 8/12
To one side lives Floyd MATTHEWS, a lawyer. On the other side lives
Willard CLARK, no profession given. Next door to him is Ben FRANKLIN, a
lawyer.

9. Death: 1914 Aug 10 Macon, Macon, Missouri. Of Zanesville Ohio.
Died at 8:00 P.M.


6 F Female Pettit
Born: 1835-1840 Abt
Christened:
Died: Unknown
Buried:
Spouse:
Marr. Date:


Events


1. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio. (5)

Unaccounted for female born about 1835 to 1840.

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.


7 F Sarah J. Pettit (7)
Born: 1838 – , , Ohio
Christened:
Died: Unknown
Buried:
Spouse:
Marr. Date:


Events


1. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio. (5)

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.


8 M Male Pettit
Born: 1835-1840 Abt
Christened:
Died: Unknown
Buried:
Spouse:
Marr. Date:


Events


1. Census: 1840 Berlin, Delaware, Ohio.

Unaccounted for male born about 1835 to 1840.

1840 OHIO DELAWARE BERLIN
pg. 210
William COCHRAN
Lovewell CAULKINS
Charlotte A. ?
Melvin T. JONES
Mary M. STONE
David LEWIS
Elizabeth LEWIS
Henry CARHART – – 1 2 1 – 1 / – – 1 – – – 1
Timothy ANDREWS
Thomas WILLIAMS
Luther CLASSON
pg. 230
Joseph P. SMITH
Aaron PETTIJOHN
James SUTTON
Ruth SNOW
James FOWLER
Bartholomew PETTIT 1 1 1 – – – 1 / 2 1 1 1 – 1
Spencer MCCOY?
William GREGG
Joseph BLAIR
Johnson MOORE
Barrel WATERS Jr.


9 M Abe Pettit (7)
Born: 1842 – , , Ohio
Christened:
Died: Unknown
Buried:
Spouse:
Marr. Date:



General Notes: Husband – Bartholomew + Pettit


Bartholomew PETTIT (of Virginia) and Sarah BUTTS had child:

Margaret b. 21 Jan. 1830, married Elliot CARHART.

SOURCE: A Genealogical Record of the Descendants of Thomas Carhart of Cornwall
England by Mary E. Carhart Dusenbury, published 1888, A. S. Barnes & Co.
(Deaths post 1888 on this page noted in the page margins by family.)

The 1850 census seems to show Bartholomew PETTIT’s household but Margaret
doesn’t appear to be in it.


General Notes: Wife – Sarah Ann (Elizabeth) + Butts


“Sarah Butts was the daughter of Zedekiah BUTTS and Margaret GRANT whose father
and brother were killed in Washington’s Army.”


Sources

1. Carhart family record.
2. Census.
3. GenForum, Hugh O. Pettit 2000 Jan 13 Pettit forum.
4. Ohio, Muskingum County, 1830 U.S. Population Schedule (Images at
Ancestry.com).
5. Ohio, Delaware County, 1840 U.S. Population Schedule (Images at
Ancestry.com).
6. Ohio, Delaware County, 1850 U.S. Population Schedule (Images at
Ancestry.com).
7. Census. …. Ohio, Delaware County, 1850 U.S. Population Schedule (Images
at Ancestry.com).
8. Ohio, Delaware County, 1860 U.S. Population Schedule (Images at
Ancestry.com).
9. Missouri, Macon County, 1870 U.S. Population Schedule (Images at
Ancestry.com).
10. Missouri, Macon County, 1880 U.S. Population Schedule (Images at
Ancestry.com).
11. Missouri, Macon County, 1900 U.S. Population Schedule (Images at
Ancestry.com).
12. Missouri, Macon County, 1910 U.S. Population Schedule (Images at
Ancestry.com).

Leave A Comment

Recent Comments